- News & Reports
- Take action
- Donate to CHAN Site
Documentary film 'When The Drum Is Beating' tells story of 'Septen'
Submitted by CHAN on April 16, 2012 - 19:58
By Roger Annis
By Larry Rohter, New York Times, April 10, 2012
Review of documentary film 'When The Drum Is Beating'
By Roger Annis
'When the Drum Is Beating' is a sixty minute film that weaves the 64-year history of the venerated Haitian band Orchestre Septentrional and the key events in Haiti during that time. Key moments in that history--the rise of Papa Doc Duvalier to power, the
overthrow of his son 25 years later, the election of Jean-Bertrand Aristide in 1990--are depicted.
Band members offer their views of the events and the evolution of the band's music. Older band members are eyewitnesses to it all. The result is a moving and informative film.
Much of the narrative of the film is provided by its director for the past ten years, François Nikol Levy. He provides insightful and witty insight into the band, its huge popularity and Haiti's music overall. Septen combines traditional themes of Haitian music with influences from jazz, funk and Cuban music. The latter influence comes through strongly via the large, brass section of the band.
Levy and other narrators also treat Haiti's social and political ills. Levy was obliged to leave Haiti several decades ago due to his outspoken views and activism against the Jean Claude Duvalier regime and the military rule that followed. He returned to Haiti from a successful career in the U.S. As he describes, he came back for the music.
This writer watched 'When the Drum Beating' hoping to forget for one hour Haiti's troubling post-earthquake crisis. Alas, it was not to be. If the film is to tell a story of Haiti's music, how can it ignore the social setting? It does not.
Consequently, the film mixes the joy and exhilaration of the band's music with the unavoidable fact that band members and the rest of the country have lived a slow and steady economic decline over the past 25 years. The latter comes through powerfully in Levy's commentary and also in the images of street scenes in Cap Haitien, Haiti's second largest city where the film is set. Then the viewer's stomach drops as the narrative reaches the earthquake of January 2010.
One element that mars the film is the explanation of the paramilitary coup of February 2004 that overthrew President Jean-Bertrand Aristide. Professor Robert Fatton serves as the principle narrator in the film of the history of Haiti. He does well, including explaining the joy and hope that erupted in Haiti when Aristide was elected president for the first time in 1990. But his description of the second coup regurgitates the worn, absurd interpretation of President Aristide that posits him as a popular hero in 1990 who became a human rights violator by the time of his second election as president in 2000.
It's a shame that the film director allows this distorted tale of 2004 to go unchallenged because, coincidentally, the film presents gripping footage of the violent assault on Cap Haitien by the paramilitaries a few weeks before the coup's denouement--the kidnapping and removal from Haiti of Aristide by U.S. marines in the early hours of February 29.
The film closes on two satisfying notes--footage of the band performing at a nightime, outdoor concert in Cap Haitien, and François Nikol Levy affirming that Haiti's salvation will not come from abroad but from within the Haitian people.
'When the Drum Is Beating' aired on select PBC stations on April 12, 2012. More broadcasts are scheduled in the coming weeks. See the television schedule here: http://www.itvs.org/films/when-the-drum-is-beating.
'Septen': For six decades, the sound of good news in Haiti
By Larry Rohter, New York Times, April 10, 2012
Since the founding of the Orchestre Septentrional in 1948, the band’s homeland, Haiti, has endured the nearly three-decade Duvalier family dictatorship, 26 other governments, a foreign intervention, a devastating earthquake and, most recently, a cholera epidemic. Through it all Septen, as the group is known to its fans, has been that rare Haitian entity that functions flawlessly.
Onstage, whether playing an elegant ballroom or an outdoors festival in the countryside, Septen is a dynamo, with a heady combination of drums and horns driving dancers onto their feet. But to Haitians, Septen’s ability to thrive when all else seems to be falling apart makes the orchestra something more — a bulwark and a solace.
“They’ve created a community institution that is really unlike anything else in Haiti,” Gage Averill, author of “A Day for the Hunter. A Day for the Prey: Popular Music and Power in Haiti” and an ethnomusicologist at the University of British Columbia. “It’s amazing. Few countries can speak of the political swings and economic challenges that Haiti can, but here’s this orchestra that even as it changes with the times, has carved out a distinct sound and approach to music making. In terms of longevity and impact, they are remarkable.”
Though little known outside Haiti and its diaspora, Septen is enjoying a burst of attention. The band is the subject of a new documentary by Whitney Dow, “When the Drum Is Beating,” that will be broadcast nationally on PBS on Thursday night (on Sunday in New York and Los Angeles) and is in the middle of a North American tour that includes three engagements this weekend in the New York metropolitan area.
“Because music is not just a source of entertainment, but one of the primary elements within Haitian culture, it offers a different path into the country,” Mr. Dow said when asked what motivated him to make the film. “Haiti is always defined by its current problem, but by mixing music and history, you can show strengths as well as weaknesses. And Septen is definitely one of those strengths.”
Like many Haitian ensembles, Septen’s rhythmic foundation draws heavily on the complex drum parts traditionally played at voodoo ceremonies and festivals. In more recent years the band has incorporated varied guitar styles from outside Haiti, the most important being chicken-scratch funk and the light and airy patterns typical of the Francophone Afro-pop heard on Haitian radio stations.
But the band’s trademark remains its large Cuban-derived brass section. Hulric Pierre-Louis, a Septen founder and its maestro for many years, used to tell stories of how as a young man growing up in Cap-Haitien on the northern coast, he would listen to radio stations in Santiago, Cuba, on the other side of the narrow Windward Passage, and transcribe the music he heard coming over the airwaves. “Haitian music is a blend of a lot of different rhythms and styles from a lot of places — from Africa, Europe, the Caribbean, Latin America,” said François Nikol Levy, a conservatory-trained keyboard player and arranger who for the past decade has been the orchestra’s musical director. “You’re going to hear that mélange in the songs Septen writes and plays.”
Mr. Dow’s film, shot from 2006 to 2010, captures Septen in a transitional stage. Younger players, steeped in funk and jazz, were being brought into the band to keep its sound current, and the discomfort of some of the veterans is palpable. “Today certain people are trying to change Septen’s sound,” Michel Tassy, a singer who joined the orchestra in 1963 and is now 68, complains to the camera. “If you do that, you get caught up in the fire. I need a little respect from the institution. Without that, things won’t work.”
Mr. Tassy remains in the orchestra and still sings lead on many of its biggest hits. But leadership onstage has clearly passed to Jocelyn Alce, a bass player who says, “I am the motor of the band,” and doesn’t mind interjecting flourishes that recall Stanley Clarke or Larry Graham into the music.
At the moment Septen’s youngest member, hired in December, is a 19-year-old saxophonist. He is not on the current tour — as is the band’s custom, he is still back in Haiti learning Septen’s repertory of more than 500 original compositions, in styles ranging from fast-moving merengues to slow and romantic boleros. But he represents the fifth generation of musicians in the band, which numbers from 14 to 19; Mr. Tassy is from the second generation.
“It’s something delicate that people don’t like to talk about, but we have to get ready for the next generation” of both musicians and fans, said Ulrich Pierre-Louis, a son of the Septen founder who is also a band manager. “Haitians consider us their own band, and we need to keep the loyalty of those fans if we are to survive.”
When on tour in Haiti, Septen travels over the country’s notoriously decrepit roads on its own bus, with a truck lugging the orchestra’s instruments, sheet music and electrical generators, necessary whenever power goes out, which is often. That truck was stolen from a show a few years ago, forcing Mr. Levy to rewrite many of the arrangements from memory.
To survive in Haiti’s harsh and unpredictable political climate, Septen has sometimes made accommodations. Mr. Dow’s film features, for example, the song “President for Life,” a homage to François Duvalier, the dictator known a s Papa Doc, that portrays Haitians as happy and flourishing under his repressive rule. It turns out, however, that the song was written under duress. As the elder Mr. Pierre-Louis tells the story in the film, a member of Duvalier’s Tonton Macoute paramilitary force came into a nightclub where Septen was playing, and sprayed the dancers and bandstand with machine-gun fire, killing an orchestra member. “We didn’t want any more problems,” Mr. Pierre-Louis, who died in 2009 at 79, told Mr. Dow.
Septen has mostly steered clear of trouble and managed to stay afloat financially by striving to become a self-contained and autonomous entity that, in contrast to other bands, does not have to rely on outside promoters, record companies or political patrons. The band even operates its own nightclub, the Feu Vert, or Green Light, in Cap-Haitien, which doubles as a rehearsal space and business office. “They had the foresight not to be dependent on other people and to instead build their own headquarters and create their own context for their music,” said Mr. Averill, the ethnomusicologist. “That they have a business plan and have been able to create this intergenerational presence is a signal achievement.”